goodhumored

Skip navigation

Windows Vista Beta 1 review and screenshots part 1

Windows Vista Beta 1 review and screenshots part 1

Microsoft has announced that their next version of Windows, codenamed Longhorn, will be named Windows Vista. Thanks to a reader who allowed me to spend some quality time with their MSDN subscription copy, I now have screenshots and an initial review.

As usual, click on the thumbnail to see each screenshot full size.


640×480

I only have one screenshot from the installation process, and it’s the big blue one here. This is what happens if you try to install Windows Vista to a blank, unformatted, unpartitioned hard drive. The Windows Vista installer can’t yet properly partition and format hard drives. To work around this problem you will need to use something else, such as a Windows XP CD, to partition and format the drive. Once you have a hard drive with an NTFS-formatted partition already on it, Windows Vista installation will begin properly. Otherwise you will receive an error stating that “Setup could not locate a locally-attached hard drive suitable to hold the temporary Windows Setup files,” even though the hard drive partitioning looks fine.

The only things the installation asked me for were the product key, the desired computer name, and where to install Windows. This is quite streamlined from previous installations.


1024×768

On first boot you will go directly into Windows. You’ll also notice that anti-virus software might not be installed (gee, you think?) and you should click this balloon to fix the problem. I’ll get to that later. For now, why don’t you eject your DVD and then re-insert it, and watch what happens.


1024×768

When you insert the Windows Vista Beta 1 DVD, this screen will appear. You can choose to run the program on the DVD, or if the disc contains multimedia content, you’ll have options to view or work with the content. You can also browse the files directly. This is pretty similar to Windows XP, so no real surprises so far.


1024×768

Okay, we had better take a look at the Start menu. First off, notice I’m logged in as Administrator. (With no password, since I was never asked to set one. I told you, the install was really streamlined.) There was no special first-boot process asking to add users or set an administrator password. It’s presumed that MSDN subscribers are smart enough to do this, but you never know. We’ll fix that and add some users later.

Before going on, take a look at the Lock and Shut down buttons. Where’s “Log off”? To log off, or get other options, click the arrow next to the button. I’ll have more to say on this later as well.


1024×768

For now, I’m going to go to the Control Panel and do some initial setup and configuration of this fresh new machine. Notice that everything is broken into categories, with subcategories or more refined choices showing below each. Most of these don’t do anything special, just going straight to the main control panel in question, and I discovered a few that did not work at all, except in Classic View.


1024×768

Okay, time to deal with that anti-virus thing. I go into Security, and it looks much the same as in Windows XP. First, I turned on Automatic Updates, just in case. Then I turned off automatic anti-virus software monitoring. You probably don’t want to do this in real life. Go get an anti-virus program; you will need it. However, I don’t know if any existing anti-virus programs work with Windows Vista. I might be able to cover this in a later article.


1024×768

Next I’m going to see if I can get a printer set up. I clicked on Printers and Faxes, and then Add Printer. It was pretty convoluted to get Windows Vista to print to my HP printer connected to my Linux server. You have to select the printer manually, set it up as an Internet printer, and go into advanced options and change the printer to LPR, and enter in the queue name. Then you have to choose the driver. If I’d made screenshots of all this, this page would have been a lot larger. LPR, in case you were unaware, is the original Unix network printing standard. Microsoft has no support for CUPS, the new Unix network printing standard, though CUPS can be combined with Samba to make Unix printers look like Windows shared printers. Certain types of high-end network printers still use the old LPR standard, though.


1024×768

I was able to successfully print to the printer, and the Windows Test Page bears no branding. It neither says Longhorn nor Vista on it. It merely says Windows. No big deal, but I was hoping to show it off. Oh well, can’t win ‘em all.


1024×768

Take a moment to hit Start, then All Programs, then Turn UAP Settings On or Off. You’ll see this dialog. Off by default in this build, User Account Protection (formerly known as Least-privileged User Account) enables you to run with a limited account, and be prompted for the administrator password when you do anything that requires administrator privileges. Mac OS X introduced this years ago, and Linux has had it for some time as well. I’ll point this out later when it comes into play.


1024×768

Okay, now it’s time to start up this much-hyped Internet Explorer 7. First thing, it tries to connect to Windows Update, which doesn’t work at all, since Windows Update has no support yet for Windows Vista. At the present time all updates for Windows Vista will come down via Automatic Updates only.


1024×768

Quit and restart Internet Explorer, and it’ll act normally. Here’s the MSN homepage in Internet Explorer 7 on Windows Vista. Note well that the location of everything has changed drastically. I spent several minutes looking for the Refresh button, for instance. So let me give you the guided tour.

The top bar contains the Back and Forward buttons, then the Address bar where you type in Web addresses, a drop-down control, then the Refresh button. When Internet Explorer is loading a page, this changes to the Stop button. After that comes the Search bar, obviously copied from Firefox. This one does MSN search, though. I’m told it can be changed, but changes itself back to MSN search. I haven’t played with it much yet to confirm this. Perhaps later.

The next bar shows the title and icon of the site you’re visiting. It doesn’t seem to have much more use than this. Why did they bother moving it off the title bar?

Finally, the customary menu bar appears. Next to it are Home, Favorites, History, Feeds, and Print buttons. I’ll cover the Feeds button below.


1024×768

Let’s see what my own web site looks like in Internet Explorer 7. Hm, not too bad. Maybe I should get around to adding that P3P code to my site to get rid of that cookie warning.

By the way, the User-Agent string for Internet Explorer 7 on Windows Vista is:

Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 7.0b; Windows NT 6.0; .NET CLR 2.0.50215; SL Commerce Client v1.0; Tablet PC 2.0)

If you install Avalon and Indigo, you get this User-Agent string instead:

Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 7.0b; Windows NT 6.0; .NET CLR 2.0.50215; SL Commerce Client v1.0; Tablet PC 2.0; Avalon 6.0.4030; WinFX RunTime 1.0.50215)

Don’t ask me about the Tablet PC thing. I don’t know. I also don’t know about SL Commerce Client; if you do, leave a comment below.


1024×768

One of the big things talked about in Internet Explorer 7 is its support for RSS feeds. Indeed, I found a couple already in the Favorites menu. So I decided to check out the IE Blog, and this is what I got. Obviously the RSS feed support still needs a lot of work, or at least a stylesheet. Hopefully this will develop further before release, or it will be pretty useless.

The Feeds button does light up and become active when the site you’re visiting has feeds available. Not all sites support this properly yet, unfortunately, even though Firefox has been doing it for years now and webmasters have had quite some time to get their sites up to date.


1024×768

Okay, time to create those user accounts. I’m going to create one administrator account for myself, and one limited user account for normal daily use. I go through the process of creating the administrator account first. I name it “error.” Much like every other account I’ve got out there.


1024×768

After that, I create the limited user account. For this purpose I named it “review.”


1024×768

Once the accounts are created, I’ll be sure and set the passwords on each of them, including the default Administrator account, which will be hidden from view as soon as I log out of it. If you have a lot of different people using your computer, turning on the Guest account might be a good idea.


1024×768

Remember the missing “Log off” option? Click on that arrow, and there it is. After a few times Windows will eventually remember that you prefer “Log off” over “Lock” and will switch the icons so that Log off shows instead. I’m going to log off now, and log back in with my new “review” account.


1024×768

The Log off dialog looks pretty normal. You can log off, or switch to another user account without logging off. I’m going to log off now, though.


1024×768

The Windows Vista login screen looks like this. To login, click the account name you want to use. Then type your password and press Enter (or click the arrow).


1024×768

And if you ever want to get into that hidden Administrator account, click on “Switch user” at the bottom, and you’ll get this complete dialog, which prompts for both username and password. You can then log on as Administrator, or any other hidden account which is enabled.


1024×768

Anyhow, I logged in as “review,” the limited user account, so I can poke around the system some more. Now if you go in the Control Panel and click on Appearance and Themes, you’ll see this. You have a lot of options, it seems, for configuring the appearance of the system and user interface functionality. It’s all here. Even Scanners and Cameras, which is rather puzzling.


1024×768

I’m not so sure I’m happy with this background, so I think I’m going to see about changing it. I click Display, and the User Account Protection comes up. Huh? Just what about changing the background requires administrator privileges? Anyway, so I put in my administrator password and the Display control panel opens.


1024×768

Unfortunately, it opens under the other window! Can you see it back there? Depending on where your windows happen to be at any given moment, you might not even be aware that anything happened! I don’t know if this is a bug, or a design decision, but it’s quite annoying. At one point I wound up with five Windows Firewall control panels open because of this. Hopefully Microsoft will fix this one.


1024×768

And now for a little interlude. Press Ctrl+Alt+Del and the Windows Security screen comes up. You can lock the computer, change your password, log off, or open the Task Manager. Wow, this is pretty. Press Esc or click Cancel to return to Windows. Did I mention it’s really pretty?


1024×768

Now it’s time to take a closer look at that Start menu. Notice Internet Explorer at the top, of course. Then Outlook Express and Windows Media Player. On the right, the usual items you expected from Windows XP, except that there’s a new one called Games. In Windows Vista, all games are expected to end up in this special area. If I get time later, I’ll go into it in more depth, but if you were looking for Freecell or Minesweeper, that’s where they are.


1024×768

Now for a big change: click on All Programs. The programs appear right here in the menu itself. You can click a folder to expand or collapse it, and a scroll bar will appear if the list becomes too long.


1024×768

I’ve expanded all the top-level folders to give an idea what this looks like with the folders expanded and the scroll bar showing. Against the darker right column the scroll bar isn’t that easy to see, so be on the lookout for it. Hopefully the theme will be tweaked a bit to make the scroll bar more clearly visible.


1024×768

Now for the most important thing you can do to a Windows computer, install Firefox. This actually turns out to be quite hairy and a royal pain, but Microsoft likes it that way, so don’t expect it to change.


1024×768

When you click on “Free Download,” first they warn you that files from the Internet could be potentially harmful, and default to Cancel. You have to click Run in order to start the download.


1024×768

Depending on your available bandwidth, the download could take a little while. If you’re on dialup, go have lunch. If you’re on broadband, go refill your coffee mug. And for Pete’s sake click that check box so that silly window doesn’t hang around after it’s done.


1024×768

Okay, now Internet Explorer is going to warn us again that files from the Internet are potentially harmful. If you click the More options button, you have the option of “Always trust software from Mozilla Foundation.” Anyway, click Run again, and you’ll soon be free of Internet Explorer. Yeah, right.


1024×768

I’m logged in to a limited user account, so I have to provide a valid administrator account and password in order to install the software. No big deal. In goes the password, and onto the computer goes Firefox. Finally!


1024×768

So after installing Firefox I start it up, and Windows Firewall decides it’s dangerous and blocks it! And there’s no Unblock button, apparently because I’m on a limited user account. So I try the “When should I unblock a program?” link, which does nothing. Apparently the Help and Support Center doesn’t work very well – or at all – in this beta.


1024×768

Another brief interlude to see what’s become of Windows Explorer. Here I’m browsing the hard drive to find where Firefox is installed, mistakenly thinking I can just right-click it to unblock it. Of course not. That would be too easy. And what’s with all the green?


1024×768

To unblock it, I had to go to Control Panel, Security, Windows Firewall, and then on the Exceptions tab, I can unblock Firefox. Hm, what is that Teredo thing and why is it there twice? Teredo, it turns out, is Microsoft’s proprietary IPv6 tunnelling protocol. Okay, fine, whatever.


1024×768

Finally! Firefox! Yes, make it my default browser! Please! I hate Internet Explorer! I even have grown to hate Internet Explorer 7.


1024×768

Okay, Part 1 is over. Time to shut the computer down. You get 30 seconds to change your mind, or you can force the issue by hitting the big button.


1024×768

Windows logs you off, and then begins shutting down all of its services.


1024×768

Windows finally shuts down.

Amazing, I didn’t kill anyone while using Windows Vista. And I got so stuck on the user interface that I didn’t even get much time to get into the underlying technologies that have bloated this version of Windows to fill 2.4GB of a DVD. I remember beta testing Windows 95. It came on thirteen floppy disks. DVDs didn’t exist. Where did all this bloat come from?

Anyway, that’s it for Part 1. Time permitting I’ll post further on Windows Vista Beta 1 and hopefully give some more coverage to the actual technologies which are built into it and/or planned for it.

6 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

28 Comments

  1. Dennis Guteman | August 2, 2005 10:26 am

    Windows XP with SP3 repackaged in a new box?

    I still remember the day XP was lauched.

    Jesus Christ!! Upgrade already!

  2. “Finally! Firefox! Yes, make it my default browser! Please! I hate Internet Explorer! I even have grown to hate Internet Explorer 7.”

    Dude that is freaking hilarious!

  3. ioerror, Do you get no sounds in vista? I have no sounds and was wondering If their is a fix. Alot of people are having this damn problem :\.

  4. “The next bar shows the title and icon of the site you’re visiting. It doesn’t seem to have much more use than this. Why did they bother moving it off the title bar?”

    thats where the tabs appear…its not just the name of the web page.

  5. XeroCool, try Installing Supplemental Drivers. If that doesn’t work you’ll have to hunt down the manufacturer’s XP driver for your sound card, which should work fine.

  6. I installed vista beta 1 on blank unformatted hd without erros.
    Nice review…..

  7. Bah…not another wind0ze err windows creation =p We’ll see how it does when it’s released. Too bad that IE is still going to be crap….I expected so much more. We’ll see how they do with it….

  8. cool avatar Jonathan…whered you get it?

  9. I was surprised that I got everything operating on my pc, including Norton AV 2005 CE. It included my Audigy 2 (2 channels only), but aside from some initial graphical problems with the geforce 6800 it was pretty easy. Oddly enough I had to install Norton twice to get it to take, even under the admin acount. Weird I know, but I am going to reinstall tonight and see if it was my error (while making a walk through). I am unsure if we can post sites or email addies on here so I’ll check back if anyone has any questions to attempt to help.

  10. Nice review. I viewed it in IE7 and it seemed to think your site is a phishing site! Check out the screenshot: http://home.comcast.net/~michael.galpin/images/ie-phish.jpg

  11. Mike, that’s funny. I haven’t seen IE7 on Windows XP yet, and I have no idea why it’s coming up with a phishing warning. I so far haven’t been able to find this anti-phishing feature in IE7 in Windows Vista.

  12. Have you at least looked at the menus? There’s the Phising Filter.

    “The next bar shows the title and icon of the site you’re visiting. It doesn’t seem to have much more use than this. Why did they bother moving it off the title bar?”

    No wonder, you haven’t even looked at the tabs!

    “This one does MSN search, though. I’m told it can be changed, but changes itself back to MSN search.”
    Not true.

    Also, your Windows don’t seem to have transparency. This is how Vista really looks like: http://www.geekpedia.com/software38_Windows-Vista-Beta-1-Screenshots.html

  13. Vandelay, thanks for letting me know. I’ll look closer at the tabs in Part 2. as for the phishing options, I didn’t see that in the Tools menu. I’ll also take another look for that as well.

    As for the transparency, that would be the Aero Glass theme, and my copy of Vista came up with it disabled. After doing some research I found that it apparently disabled itself because it doesn’t like the video card. Oh well. Glass-free screenshots, I suppose, unless I can figure out how to enable it anyway. Supposedly Tweak Vista can do this.

  14. Unless you have a really old graphics card, try installing updated drivers. Perhaps Vista didn’t recognize the graphics card and installed a standard driver.

  15. Enterprise environment….tested Vista – huge problems with Kerberos and NAS – as in … I can’t access my NAS server AT ALL….

    sux. Other than it’s been pretty good.

    I’ve scoured blogs and MS – but no kerberos fix – ran into other users with the same issue but they didn’t post any fixes.

  16. Vandelay, thanks for the suggestion. I’ll see what I can manage.

    Robert, I am afraid I don’t know about Kerberos either. But if I run across a solution I’ll post it here.

  17. Hmm well this doesnt exact;y look what I thought it was going to be to be honest. I was thinking the bad on the left with the clock etc would be there. Although there are some changes it looks pretty much the same as Xp.

  18. yeh luks prtty gd lyk.prob gona b buyin it soon.

  19. SiMp5oN - MACEDONIA | August 25, 2005 2:40 pm

    WINDOWS VISTA SUCK`S!!! It`s new XP release with SP 3!!!
    LINUX RULZ!!!

  20. I’ve been using Windows my whole life. I was pretty excited about Windows XP. Then I switched to Linux. For the past year, I haven’t touched Windows except to play Pro Evolution Soccer! I don’t mean to be partial here, just because I prefer Linux over Windows. But, looking at this review and the screenshots etc, I see more of the same with added eye-candy.

    Now, I’ve become a hard-core geek. I can honestly see Microsoft trying to emulate Unix/Linux. The only difference being, all these great features are available to me on the CLI (though KDE/Gnome do make a good job of providing very fine GUI’s to most of the stuff, along with other apps of course!). The Windows way is with pretty graphical interfaces.

    I wouldn’t want to make unhealthy comments like SiMpSoN before me has done, but honestly, I don’t think I would want to spend my money on Vista…

    Something I really believe in… Linux teaches you actually use your computer.. Windows teaches you to point and click!

    But, like I said, I don’t want to be partial. Vista does look very nice. (I’m talking about the graphical interface!) Apart from the looks, atleast in this beta release, I don’t see anything really new or special. Though for people who only care about the eye candy and “ease of use” Vista does look good. For us geeks, we have Linux ;)

  21. get BSD

  22. i need an antivirus program for microsoft vista beta 1. norton isn’t working

  23. Darlyn Perez | May 10, 2006 8:07 pm

    This review is the best one I’ve seen so far. That’s exceptionally good, considering the tons of reviews I’ve read about Vista. Very informative and sticks to the point. The screen shots also help out big time.

    Anyway, my opinion on Mrugesh’s above comment (second post above this one):
    Thanks for dawning the reality of Vista into words: It’s just added eye-candy and really nothing majorly new. The new Desktop Widgets, which were obviously copied from the Mac, don’t really add much to the usability of Windows. And come to think of it, all Windows does really is teach you to point and click, unless you’re a geek like me and decide to toy (and hack) with all of the internal components regular users never know exist (things that are mostly in the system32 folder).

    Please do not take this as my opposition to Windows; I am a huge hardcore fan and user of Windows and have always(and will most likely for ever)used it. I have even refitted my Windows XP to look exactly like Vista, ranging from the Log-on screen to the user interface. Kudos again on the review, Michael Hampton and thanks for inspiring me to try Linux one day, Mrugesh.

    -Darlyn Perez

  24. If any of you are having problems with Vista logon to NAS devices running Samba, try:

    Run secpol.msc

    Go to: Local Policies > Security Options

    Find “Network Security: LAN Manager authentication level”

    Change Setting from “Send NTLMv2 response only”
    to
    “Send LM & NTLM – use NTLMv2 session security if negotiated”

    Vista defaults to only send the more secure NTLMv2 protocol, which these NAS devices / Samba do not support.

  25. I installed Windows Vista beta 1, but i cannot login, he ask me Username and Password.. and i dont know that username and password.. whre can that??

  26. using windows vista ..when i click on a e-mail link in a
    web page
    it opens 45 explorer windows and gives an error message

    default mail is out look
    web browser is ie 7

    im not sure if it a problem w/ vista ,outlook or ie 7

  27. !!!!!!!!! UPDATE WINDOWS VISTA IS SOFA KING GHAY…..
    NOTHING FOLLOWS>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

  28. I downgraded from RTM to Beta 1 and I love the switch.
    Beta 1 looked so much better than this ugly RTM.

    The shell for every window was amazing. Loved the green, orange and blue.

    Performance is better than one of RTM, games run faster.
    Installed like a charm on a 2nd HD.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.
(optional)

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Please read our comment policy before leaving your comment.