Two high school newspapers censored

November 30, 2005 @ 9 Comments

A completely informal survey of my readers recently revealed that a significant minority of them are still in high school. This article is for you. Welcome to America, land of the censored. It doesn’t get much better when you’re an adult.

Hammer of Truth runs down the story of a school in Oak Ridge, Tenn., which last week traced down and pulled every copy of the student newspaper, The Oak Leaf, at Oak Ridge High School which ran two controversial articles about birth control and tattoos.

“The school administration should realize they don’t have the power to censor our paper,” Thomas said, while fellow students gathered around her living room late Wednesday afternoon to hand-paint T-shirts they plan to wear to school on Monday in protest.

“When they (the general population) see a pregnant girl, they say the girl should know better,” senior Samantha Senn said. “But in a lot of cases, they (the girls) don’t know anything.”

Other students said they think not allowing the paper to be distributed at school is “ridiculous.”

The article which explains birth control methods references a national survey, conducted in 2001, of high school students who were asked whether they were sexually active. Those national percentages were applied to ORHS students.

The article primarily covers birth control methods, quotes Dr. Charles Darling, an obstetrician/gynecologist in Oak Ridge, and tells students where they may obtain contraceptives — including a quote from Darling that says parental consent is not needed to obtain birth control.

According to the paper’s Editor-in-Chief, Brittany Thomas an article placed underneath the offending story, “advises students to practice abstinence until marriage.”

Oak Ridge High School Principal Becky Ervin ordered the search and seizure. . . .

In support of the censorship, Oak Ridge Schools Superintendent Tom Bailey said: “We have a responsibility to the public to do the right thing. We’ve got 14-year-olds that read the [student] newspaper.”

School officials also object to an article about tattoos and body piercings.

According to Superintendent Bailey, the newspaper will be reprinted with all of the offending material deleted. — Tennessee Independent Media Center

The paper was reprinted and distributed today, without the birth control article, and with revisions made to the article on tattoos. Perhaps they should have done what this next person did.

And Irregular Times reports on the Student Press Law Center, which covers issues of censorship in high school. It reported on Dwight Greer, assistant principal at Beachwood High School in Bradenton, Fla., who censored student Max Eden’s independent student paper, The Bison Blowhard.

Greer, who did not return multiple calls seeking comment for this story, told a local paper, The Sun Press, that due to the Blowhard’s content there was a likelihood for disruption.

But Greer had not seen a hard copy of the paper before he made his decision, Eden said. He only had an idea about its content after word circulated among the student body about what the paper was going to cover.

According to the Sun Press, articles in The Blowhard described the football team as arrogant, said the homecoming queen election was rigged and described a dehumanizing hazing assembly, among other topics. The paper did not use any names.

Eden said he told Greer he believed he was within his rights to distribute the paper under the 1969 Tinker v. Des Moines Supreme Court ruling. That ruling recognized that the First Amendment protects students’ free speech rights while at school.

Eden said Greer then told him that under Tinker, student speech can be censored if it is believed that the material will cause a substantial disruption.

Greer told Eden that “if you want to distribute it off school grounds then you have every right under your constitutional rights. But if you choose to distribute it on school grounds, you will be suspended, based on the likelihood that it will cause a disruption in the school,” according to The Sun Press article.

To avoid suspension, Eden said he passed out 50 or 60 copies of The Blowhard at a local mall. He said there has not been a real reaction from students to the paper, except for classmates commending him for writing about issues that needed to be written about. The local library is also distributing the paper, he said. — Student Press Law Center

Many high school students say that their school administrators are arbitrary, capricious and make poor decisions. And that’s putting it nicely. What’s going on in your high school that administrators don’t want you to know about?

9 Comments → “Two high school newspapers censored”


  1. Matt

    Jan 25, 2007

    Actually, it’s Beachwood Ohio dumbasses. How do I know? I go there & I know Max Eden.
    Other than that, good work with this article.


  2. joe

    Apr 12, 2007

    this is bull I think all school newspaper should be censored


  3. Donna

    Sep 27, 2007

    Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier
    Says
    In the Hazelwood decision, the Court said that a different test would apply to censorship by school officials of student expression in a school-sponsored activity such as a student newspaper that was not a public forum for student expression. When a school’s decision to censor is “reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns,” it will be permissible.4 In other words, if a school can present a reasonable educational justification for its censorship, that censorship will be allowed.

    However the students should still contact the student press law center for help

    Peace


  4. Anonymous

    Nov 27, 2007

    it’s type ridiculous that we teenagers arent allowed to have an opinoin any more, every thing is beeing controlled by the adults opinion who the hell are they to tell what we can or can’t express. somone one some where i sure would benefit from your article, i say hell yeah publish it!!!

    Leah T, from Brooklyn NY


  5. Anonymous

    Dec 20, 2007

    supid this stink u shuld get a job


  6. Dawn

    Jan 15, 2008

    It’s good to have high school newspapers censored. My children attend a public highschool and I like that their
    school newspapers is censored. Besides, it’s not like they don’t get enough of that stuff every single day. They probably hear it all in the hallways daily as it is. Censoring is the best way to go.


  7. Anonymous

    Jan 07, 2010

    freedom of press and speech, first amendment.


  8. Anonymous

    Mar 01, 2010

    We have the power to express ourselves, even though we are miniors we still considered U.S. citizens.


  9. Student Journalist

    Jun 09, 2010

    Hallway chatter often consists of myth, not fact.
    Proper journalism doesn’t need censorship because it provides factual information. Which sounds exactly what this high school newspaper was doing.

    Censorship doesn’t help students learn.

    For the most part I agree with Donna, the Student Press Law Center is the way to go.
    Many high school newspapers, like the one I previously wrote for, are facing illegal acts of prior review and prior restraint. That is, the administrators censor on whim, not for pedagogical reasons.


Leave a Reply

Copyright © 2012 Homeland Stupidity.

Bad Behavior has blocked 3479 access attempts in the last 7 days.