The UK Press Complaints Commission, a regulatory body for the newspaper and magazine industry, has called for a “voluntary code of conduct” for blogs similar to the one adhered to by the mainstream press.
Claiming that blogs offer “no means of redress” and have “no professional standards”, PCC director Tim Toulmin claimed that the Internet was “how the newspaper industry would look like if it was unchecked”.
Under the PCC-suggested system, all bloggers would adhere to “self-imposed regulation”; despite this, Toulmin claims that he is not in favour of “regulating the internet”:
“We’re not in favour of regulating the internet. The flow of information should not be regulated by any government.” — BBC News
Toulmin also described the terms “free speech” and “free press” as “relative”, citing libel laws and data protection as examples of two justified encroachments on free speech. Self regulation, Toulmin claims, can be similarly justified.
The PCC’s comments come at a time when divisions between the mainstream press and bloggers are becoming increasingly blurred. In August, for example, blogger Josh Wolf was imprisoned for failing to hand over unpublished video footage in laws designed to apply to mainstream reporters.
Such attempts to “rein in” the hitherto anarchistic atmosphere of online publishing have met with strong protests from many online bloggers, and the tensions between regulated and unregulated media are unlikely to come to a head any time soon — particularly considering the passionate reactions such attempts have created thus far.
Cleanthes
Dec 01, 2006
Rob,
Thanks for the link. The situation in the UK is further complicated by the fact that – as I’m sure you and most of your readers will be aware – the UK does not have the same constitutional guarantee of the freedom of speech and our libel laws are very much more open to abuse than yours in the US – witness the Irving/Lipstadt trial, where Irving took the action in London for a book published in the US.
That is not to say that truth is not a defence: Irving was squashed like a bug and deservedly so.
All of that said, I had hoped that my post was more “considered” than “passionate”: it’s just that any sensible analysis of this topic can really only come out as a sound bug-squashing Toulmin and that toe-rag Campbell.
Toodle Pip!
Cleanthes
Rob Miller
Dec 01, 2006
I’m in the UK too, BTW :)
I absolutely detest our libel laws, perhaps more than anything else in English law. We could at least implement the recommendations by the ECHR (following the McLibel case) but I doubt that’ll ever happen. Meh.