The Joshua Bell busking, or, pearls before bureaucrats

April 13, 2007 @ Michael Hampton9 Comments

Joshua Bell is perhaps America’s finest classical musician. Just this week he accepted the Avery Fisher Prize for his accomplishments. I admit I wouldn’t know; I’ve never been much into classical music. But I can recognize stupidity anywhere.

On January 12, in connection with a social experiment by theWashington Post, Joshua Bell played a very unusual concert in a very unusual hall: For 43 minutes, he pretended to be a street musician at the L’Enfant Plaza Metro station in Washington, D.C., playing his $3.5 million Stradivarius.

And as a feature in last week’sPost Magazine has it, 1,097 people passed by in that time, virtually all of them government employees, and virtually none of them noticing.

Voice of the Violin

I can’t possibly excerpt enough of the article to give you a feeling for it, but I will invite you to open the audio of Bell’s performance in a new window while you read.

Because, despite being a classical violinist, Bell has a sense of humor and knows how to have fun.

(The experiment had to be conducted on a rare piece of private property in the Metro system, because as the Cato Institute’s Jim Harper points out, the government bureaucrats wouldn’t allow it to be conducted on Metro property. The writer, Gene Weingarten, explains how he got the idea for the story and how dealing with the Metro bureaucracy was an eight-day nightmare, while securing permission from the private property manager took “six seconds.” But there’s more going on here than just one bureaucracy.)

Here are a few cuts from the magazine article, which you should read in full:

When Bell was asked if he’d be willing to don street clothes and perform at rush hour, he said:

“Uh, a stunt?”

Well, yes. A stunt. Would he think it . . . unseemly?

Bell drained his cup.

“Sounds like fun,” he said. . . .

In the three-quarters of an hour that Joshua Bell played, seven people stopped what they were doing to hang around and take in the performance, at least for a minute. Twenty-seven gave money, most of them on the run — for a total of $32 and change. That leaves the 1,070 people who hurried by, oblivious, many only three feet away, few even turning to look.

It was all videotaped by a hidden camera. You can play the recording once or 15 times, and it never gets any easier to watch. Try speeding it up, and it becomes one of those herky-jerky World War I-era silent newsreels. The people scurry by in comical little hops and starts, cups of coffee in their hands, cellphones at their ears, ID tags slapping at their bellies, a grim danse macabre to indifference, inertia and the dingy, gray rush of modernity.

Even at this accelerated pace, though, the fiddler’s movements remain fluid and graceful; he seems so apart from his audience — unseen, unheard, otherworldly — that you find yourself thinking that he’s not really there. A ghost.

Only then do you see it: He is the one who is real. They are the ghosts. — Washington Post Magazine

There’s the woman exiting the Metro whose child tries to stop and listen. She drags him along and out the door and was completely oblivious, too focused on going wherever she was going. The thousand or so government employees on their way to another day of making hell of ordinary people’s lives. They ignored the greatest classical musician in America.

And I can’t help but think how dehumanized almost everyone in this sad story has become. It’s hard to keep your humanity when you work for the government, when your day consists of enforcing arbitrary and capricious rules on other people. You yourself have been turned from a human being, capable of both reason and emotion, to a machine which steers other people through a maze of rules and regulations and punishes those who step outside the box. Why see the ordinary people forced to be your bureaucracy’s “customers” as human? Stay in line, follow the rules, and you’ll get by.

If that’s all life is to be, forget it. That sort of bleak existence is hardly worth contemplating.

And while this bleak, regimented almost-life afflicts government bureaucrats more than the rest of us, it certainly isn’t limited to them. Most of us don’t quite live our lives, but just trudge through each day as though we were Sisyphus pushing rocks up the hill, only to do it all again the next day. Too few of us, too little of the time, stop to appreciate the beauty and wonder that is life.

And that’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever seen.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

9 Comments → “The Joshua Bell busking, or, pearls before bureaucrats”


  1. Jeff Hoyt

    Apr 13, 2007

    The best piece yet, Michael. Outstanding!

    Reply

  2. James O'Donnell

    Apr 13, 2007

    Great piece Mike, and yet another ringing endorsement for the DC and northern Virginia area, which is conformist, vanilla, boring, non-creative, and marches in step and en masse to all things government. The only thing that surprises me is some badged, maniacal government employee didn’t call in the great musician as some sort of terrorist threat to conformity and civil order. Whilst DC police would have ignored it due to malaise, I’m sure the Feds would have swooped in backed up by volunteer police officers from Fairfax and Loudon counties, as they have little to do, little mental ability, and lots of time and money.

    Reply

  3. Michelle

    Apr 13, 2007

    There is a great response to the Joshua Bell article by a NYC subway musician in her blog.
    She interprets the situation differently from the Washington Post reporters… I thought you might find it interesting.

    Reply

  4. Ray

    Apr 14, 2007

    Then again we seem to have an example of 7 people who are dumb enough to actually like classical music an 27 who recognize someone who needs help to actually learn what real music is ;-)

    and we have 1,070 people who are smart enough to keep walking until some real music shows up.

    Reply
  5. Apr 17, 2007

    Reply

  6. geri

    Apr 17, 2007

    There is another side to this as well. Most people assume that those standing on street corners or even in places like the Metro and expecting money are…well, bums…homeless and looking for a handout. No matter how sweetly they play the music.

    It’s a natural inclinition and the most obvious response is to block them out and pretend they aren’t there because it would be horrible to admit that, one day, you could be there too.

    How do I know? Because I’ve been there. Yup, done the homeless thing…with kids in tow…and it is dehumanizing and not many places take the time to welcome you into humanity once you’ve fallen that far.

    Thank goodness I found a place that did and that gave me some training so that I could get a good job and get on my feet again. They helped the whole person, not just the one that needed shelter and food like most shelters do.

    It’s sad that we try to ignore realities like that…but we do and, let me tell you, it doesn’t make them better.

    Reply

  7. Jeff Hoyt

    Apr 17, 2007

    Good point, geri, and well spoken.

    Reply

  8. Ray

    Apr 17, 2007

    Sorry to hear about your life Geri. I am glad to hear things are better. But from having worked for several organizations which work with the homeless, I am say that most of tghe homeless don’t really want help. All they want is a hand out, and pretty much demand it, and demand that this be without strings like trying to get your life going again. People like you who actually want to do the things that get them off the street are a very small minority. Most organizations dedicated to helping the homeless are organized around this reality.

    Organizations which try and help mostly try to keep the homeless alive until this very few show themselves and then to acutally provide real help to these.

    Reply

  9. geri

    Apr 18, 2007

    A sad but true point, Ray. I do know this also. And, with the fact that…at least here in NC…so many ‘government funded’ psych hospitals are going under and turning people out onto the streets daily it’s not going to get better.

    There are those that want help. There are those who expect help and there are those who don’t know how to get help. There are also those that are mentally incapable of doing anything but moving through their days one day at a time trying to survive.

    I work in the field now as an administrative assistant and it’s hard to see people who simply won’t help themselves or who don’t feel that they are worth helping anymore. Or don’t believe it CAN get any better. Society has a big part in that as well in the way of working wages, etc.

    I also see that there are many that embrace the help and go on to better lives. Even for a few, society should lift their heads out of the sand and at least try. There may not be a thousand thank yous in this job but the one you do get is worth all the time and effort you put into it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Copyright © 2010 Homeland Stupidity.